The Unorthodox Captain Selection That Raised Eyebrows
When Unai Emery asked his Arsenal squad to vote for their next captain, it wasn’t just a tactical decision—it was a statement. The eventual appointment of Granit Xhaka, alongside a leadership group featuring Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang, Hector Bellerin, Alexandre Lacazette, and Mesut Özil, sparked debates across the football world. But what does this reveal about Arsenal’s current state under Emery?
Does Emery Lack a True Leader?
Martin Samuel of the Daily Mail didn’t hold back: “Having five captains doesn’t mean you have five strong leaders—it means you have none.” Drawing parallels to Germany’s 2002 World Cup squad, which named six strikers due to uncertainty, Samuel argued that Emery’s approach reflects a lack of trust in any single player to lead.
Historically, Arsenal thrived under iconic captains like Tony Adams and Patrick Vieira—figures who commanded respect through sheer presence. In contrast, Emery’s committee-style leadership suggests a shift away from traditional authority, raising questions about the squad’s mentality.
Xhaka: The Right Choice or a Compromise?
Xhaka’s appointment divides opinion. On one hand, he’s a seasoned international with 100+ caps for Switzerland and a vocal presence. On the other, his costly mistakes—like the reckless challenges and positional lapses that have cost Arsenal points—make him a controversial pick.
Darren Lewis (Daily Mirror) noted: “If you’re polling players to pick a captain, it implies the manager lacks conviction.” While Xhaka’s popularity in the dressing room is undeniable, his selection feels more like a democratic compromise than a decisive managerial call.
The Modern Manager’s Dilemma: Fear of Offending Players?
Steve Bates (Sunday People) highlighted a growing trend: managers avoiding singular leadership roles to prevent locker-room friction. “Today’s coaches talk about collective responsibility, but true leadership isn’t about pleasing everyone,” he argued. The reluctance to appoint a single captain risks diluting accountability—a stark contrast to the “one voice” ethos of Arsenal’s Invincibles era.
Banglawin Verdict: Leadership by Committee Rarely Works
While Emery’s inclusive approach aligns with modern management trends, football’s greatest teams often hinge on a singular, authoritative figure. Xhaka’s leadership will be tested immediately, starting with high-pressure fixtures like the upcoming clash against Manchester United.
For more cutting-edge analysis, stay tuned to Banglawin—your go-to source for fearless football insights.
What’s your take? Is Xhaka the right captain, or should Emery have taken a firmer stance? Share your thoughts below and follow Banglawin for the latest updates!
